High-value Beanie Babies like Piccadilly Attic can fetch over $100,000 due to errors in coloration. Rare versions of Batty the Bat with an extra foot can be worth up to $7,000. Beanie Baby Jolly the ...

It turns out that the shoebox in the attic might be worth more than a few dusty memories. While not every Beanie Baby from the ’90s has held its promised value, specific rare versions—especially those ...

From ultra-rare treasures to childhood staples, the Beanie Baby craze of the 90s gave us collectibles of all kinds! Join us as we explore the stuffed animals you'd need a miracle to find today and the ...